The Muser
 
  copyright notice
The Muser
Home
3rd Party
National Debt
Color
Cinema
Denver History
Vignettes
Great Reality
The Blog
On Musing
Recent Musings
Muser's Bio
Email Muser

Musings

Cloning

Bombing Afghanistan

Stem Cells

Florida 2000

Curmudgeonry

Elvis, Messiah?

 

Recent Musings
Ramblings of the Muser's Mind Earlier Featured As Current Musings

On Curmudgeonry:

I and a colleague at The Art Institute of Colorado, were boasting to an associate one day about our cultivated curmudgeonry.  Some discussion of the word "curmudgeon" followed, and I was inspired to consult several dictionaries. (One is seldom sufficient.)

cur·mudg·eon (k.r-m¾j".n) n. An ill-tempered person full of resentment and stubborn notions. --cur·mudg"eon·ly adj. --cur·mudg"eon·ry n.
The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Third Edition; 1992

an irascible, churlish person;
The Random House Dictionary of the English Language, The Unabridged Edition; 1967

a surly, ill-mannered, bad-tempered person; cantankerous fellow;
Webster's New World Dictionary of the American Language; 1978

[perh. From medieval name Curmegan, perh. Equivalent to FR. Coeur méchant, evil heart] an avaricious, churlish fellow; a miser; a cantankerous fellow.
Webster's New Universal Unabridged Dictionary; Second Edition; 1983

A fascinating lexicographic journey through the world of curmudgeonry (which is shown as a legitimate form, along with "curmudgeonly," in at least one of my dictionaries): 

What a wealth of adjectives applies to this state! Only one phrase is repeated in these four definitions. Only one dictionary took a stab at the derivation, and it is a generally poor dictionary; I seldom find it helpful.

 Note that most of the definitions are gender-neutral, but the word "fellow" appears three times. The Random House , probably the best reputed of these books says "person." It specifically says the derivation is unknown.

 Certainly I have some stubborn notions, and I suppose I'm a bit cantankerous, but I really don't think I'm surly or ill-tempered.  I've always attached a sense of intellectualism, or perhaps sophistication to the word, making a curmudgeon distinct from a simple low-class grouch. None of these lexicographers agrees with me.

Appalling!

Copyright © 1997 J. C. Adamson

Top
copyright © 2010, J. C. Adamson